At the height of the 2005 election, the then Tory leader Michael Howard (advised by one Lynton Crosby) declared:
‘Let’s be clear. It’s not racist to talk about immigration. It’s not racist to criticise the system. It’s not racist to want to limit the numbers. It’s just plain common sense.’
Howard was lambasted by Labour for the speech, with cabinet ministers wheeled out to slam the Conservatives for ‘scurrilous, right-wing, ugly tactics’.
Fast forward nine years and Yvette Cooper’s soundbite sounds a little familiar. In a speech today, Labour’s Shadow Home Secretary declared:
‘It isn’t racist to be worried about immigration or to call for immigration reform.’
Even one of the campaign’s posters (above) used Cooper’s line. What changed, eh?
P.S.: You can see why Cooper is touchy about this. Voters associate the Labour years with soaring immigration, for reasons explained in the below graph:
Subscribe to The Spectator today for a quality of argument not found in any other publication. Get more Spectator for less – just £12 for 12 issues.