Nick Boles has always been one of the most intellectually interesting Tory modernisers. Back in 2010, he caused controversy with his call for a formal electoral pact between the two coalition parties. But today, he has recanted that idea and instead proposed that the Tories create an internal coalition by reforming the National Liberal Party as their sister party.
Boles concedes that his idea for an electoral pact was flawed because the Liberal Democrats aren’t a ‘Liberal’ party but instead a ‘statist party of the soft left’. In a sign of the loss of personal respect for Clegg even among liberal Tory ministers, Boles attacks the deputy Prime Minister as a ‘principle-free zone’ who is happy to cut a coalition deal with anyone however illiberal. He also warns that too many Tories have gone along with the Lib Dem game of doing ‘everything in their power to paint us as heartless extremists’.
But what will get the headlines is Boles call for the Tories to revive the National Liberal Party as a sister party. Boles’ case is that:
‘The Conservative Party will only rebuild itself as a national party which can win majorities on its own if it understands that it cannot do so by making a single undifferentiated pitch to every age group and in every part of the country’
He believes that a National Liberal party, which would work in tandem with the Tory party, would have a particularly good chance of wooing younger, more liberal voters. He warns that the Tories ‘have no hope of securing their support if we approach them with the same proposition that we use to woo our stalwart supporters.’
Boles’ idea will ruffle feathers. Some will see it as a distraction from the importance of reviving the Tory brand. Others will dislike the idea of a sister party. But there is a strong argument that it would be far better for the Tory party to construct its own coalition before polling day rather than being forced into one with somebody else afterwards.
Subscribe to The Spectator today for a quality of argument not found in any other publication. Get more Spectator for less – just £12 for 12 issues.