Skip to Content

Coffee House

Osborne goes on the offensive

1 March 2011

9:00 AM

1 March 2011

9:00 AM

Attack, attack, attack. That’s the temper of George Osborne’s article for the Guardian this morning, which sets about Labour’s economic credibility with a ferocious sort
of glee. Perhaps the best passage is where he asks how many times Labour can spend their ubiquitous "bank tax," but this is more pertinent to the recent debate:

"Where does all this leave Ed Miliband’s newfound enthusiasm for the "squeezed middle"? Let’s pass over his failure in every interview to define it – his last effort
included around 90% of taxpayers. Where we can all agree is that these are difficult times for family incomes. There are two root causes. One is global: rises in food and commodity prices. The
other is specific to the UK: the unwinding, through a 25% currency depreciation and an unavoidable fiscal consolidation, of economic imbalances built up under Labour. That is why the governor of
the Bank of England has said that ‘the real consequences of this crisis are only now beginning to be felt’.

My party learned the hard way over 13 years that opposition without a credible alternative tends to remain just that: opposition. The real squeeze is not on the middle, but on Labour’s
muddle."

There are two things worth noting from all that. First, that Osborne does concede that "these are difficult times for family incomes" – not that he’d say otherwise, of
course, but accepting that there is a problem is almost the same as accepting the need for solutions.


And then there’s his case that UK inflation is being boosted by "a 25% currency depreciation and an unavoidable fiscal consolidation." There’s only one part of that that anyone could
really quibble with: the "unavoidable" part. And that’s the problem for Osborne. If people do not accept that aspects of the fiscal consolidation – such as the VAT rise – are
"unavoidable," the the coalition will still catch the flak from rising prices.

Thing is, it isn’t just Ed Balls who is circling around the VAT hike. The measure has plenty of opponents on the right as well, including Guido and a shoal of free market think-tanks. Little wonder why Osborne is shaping for a
scrap.  

P.S. As the Mervyn King quotation that Osborne references is buried inside a recent Q&A
document
, I thought I’d paste the full excerpt below. So, here’s the Governor of the Bank of England:

"Given that we’ve seen these very large rises in commodity and energy prices, the real consequences of this crisis and the need to rebalance our economy are only now being felt. They
weren’t felt in 2008; they are now beginning to be felt. And this will come through over a considerable period. That’s why we face a difficult time ahead."

Show comments
Close