Coffee House

Field gets to work

11 June 2010

9:07 AM

11 June 2010

9:07 AM

The Times leads with the story that Frank Field, the government’s independent poverty advisor, is recommending that child benefit
be stopped at age 13, arguing that: ‘at that age mothers feel even more engaged with work than they are with children.’

Currently, the benefit is paid until children are 19 – £20 is paid for the first child and £13.40 for each subsequent child. The benefit costs the taxpayer £11bn per year;
Field’s proposal would save £3bn a year and there would be considerably larger savings if the cut was extended to child tax credits.

Field and IDS will propose radical reform of incapacity and out of work benefits that will incur significant upfront costs – around £3bn by some estimates – so savings have to be
made elsewhere on the welfare bill. In addition to the savings Field envisages, he wants to tax universal child benefit along the lines of income tax bands, to ensure that the poorest receive
the bulk of the benefit. He argues that a tax option would be cheaper than means testing; it is also politically sound: the benefit would remain universal, which would disarm Labour’s likely
line of attack that the government wants to create a two-tier welfare system that would maroon the poor. Field would also introduce a ‘life chances index’, which would measure family
income, parenting and school readiness (holding a crayon etc), as the means to assess child poverty and to allocate funds appropriately.

Subscribe to The Spectator today for a quality of argument not found in any other publication. Get more Spectator for less – just £12 for 12 issues.


Show comments
Close