Blogs Coffee House

The cloning industry may be closer than you think

15 April 2014

2:55 PM

15 April 2014

2:55 PM

A cute puppy is natural front-page fodder, as the birth of Britain’s first cloned puppy last week proved. When it was announced that Rebecca Smith, from London, had won a competition to clone her miniature dachshund, Winnie – and that the procedure had been successful – the papers were full of puppy pics.

The science of cloning isn’t ground breaking; we’ve all heard about Dolly the sheep, and the world’s first cloned dog, Snuppy, was born in 2005. So why was there such a fuss about the latest puppy – and why is cloning a dog so different from cloning any other animal?  They already clone horses. In fact, in some equine disciplines, cloning is becoming a major industry. Well, if you can afford it, that is. In 2013 it was announced that Tamarillo, an eventer who won both Badminton and Burghley with William Fox Pitt, had been cloned at a reported cost of £104,000.


When it comes to polo, it’s done on a different scale; Adolfo Cambiaso – considered by most to be the best player in the world – has had around 100 clones of his favourite horses created, and in December won the Argentine Open (polo’s equivalent of the World Cup) playing on a pony from his cloned string. Nor do these clones come cheap; one was sold at auction in 2010 for almost £500,000. And Rio 2016 will be the first Olympics to allow cloned horses to compete, after the Féderation Equestre Internationale lifted a ban on them in 2012.

But cloning a horse is somewhat different from cloning a pet dog. For better or for worse, when cloning a horse, you’re probably cloning it for its genetic traits; its superior speed, agility or, arguably, intelligence.  When it comes to cloning a family pet however, as Rebecca has, it’s more likely to be the animal’s character and personality you’re looking to replicate. And even now, does anyone really know how much of that attitude and character is owed to nature, and how much to nurture? Unless that dog has exactly the same upbringing and experiences as the original (and what are the chances of that?), it’s unlikely to behave in the exact same way.

Ethically – well, that’s a different kettle of fish. Horses aren’t mere machines, and the worry is that our ability to recreate them so easily will encourage us to treat them as commodities, rather than as animals. Animal cloning, despite being scientifically viable, is still very much a hit and miss technique. The first cloned dog was the only one to survive out of 1,095 cloned embryos, and critics are wary of what, exactly, happens to the surrogate mothers when they are no longer needed – particularly in the Far East.

There are other worries too, of course. It’s hardly a natural process; so just how far should humans be able to interfere with the production of new life? And when we start cloning animals for pets or sports, is it really that big a step from there, to cloning animals for food production? But seeing as many people still struggle with the concept of genetically modified plants, it seems unlikely that we’ll be seeing cloned dairy cattle anytime soon.

Subscribe to The Spectator today for a quality of argument not found in any other publication. Get more Spectator for less – just £12 for 12 issues.

Show comments
  • Chance Lee

    Yes plant cloning is used by the gardener to make the new
    plant more fruitful than that the old one. But in case of animal it’s a very
    big task to perform. Thanks for your post.
    Clone King

  • Alison Mercer

    sad because there are enough horses for everyone already and I think it is awful to be so obsessed with perfection and in the end itis the animals who will suffer. they already do as you obviously know being a racehorse rescue ! I think it is an empty dream and if you can’t see the beauty in all horses you aren’t really an animal lover.

  • Smithersjones2013

    Heh? Labour have been at it for at least two decades (resistance is futile you will be assimilated) and given the witless observations of the government clearly the Tories and Libdems have had programs in place for sometime now.

  • Kitty MLB

    Didn’t we once have a cloned pig or a sheep, I am sure we did not so long ago.
    There is something quite sinister about something being artificially created.
    Just imagine cloned humans, lots of little Milipede’s creating mayhem.
    No its against nature and heading into darkness- I feel it in my water.

    • Hexhamgeezer

      Agreed. A Star Wars documentary informs us that the clones start fighting everyone. It’ll all end in tears.

    • telemachus

      In principle you may be correct but the example you chose did not illustrate your point well
      Most of us would be delighted to have a few more folk in politics of the calibre and integrity of Miliband

    • El_Sid

      There is something quite sinister about something being artificially created.

      So you’re against IVF then?

  • Hexhamgeezer

    So Nick Clegg isn’t a clone?