Coffee House

PMQs sketch: In which Cameron both chooses and answers the questions.

13 February 2013

4:54 PM

13 February 2013

4:54 PM

Whoosh! Crasshh! Ploophm! Crummppp! The personal attacks came pounding in on David Cameron today. Ed Miliband asked about declining living standards and set about portraying the prime minister as an out-of-touch toff surrounded by plutocratic parasites. He cited the recent Tory Winter Ball where a signed mug-shot of Mr Cameron had been auctioned for the Warhol-esque sum of £100,000.

‘Then the prime minister declared, without a hint of irony, that the Tories are no longer the party of privilege.’

Cameron ignored the issue of living standards and told Miliband he’d raised the wrong topic.

‘If his question is – have you had to take difficult decisions to deal with the deficit, reform welfare and clean up the banks? Then yes, you bet.’

Interesting. The PM gets to choose the questions and the answers. It wouldn’t work in court. ‘Did you murder your wife?’ ‘No, I’ve never scrumped an apple.’

Cameron pulled the same trick when Stephen Pound asked if he stood to benefit personally from the millionaires’ tax-cut in April. The PM replied by acquitting himself of defrauding the Revenue.

‘I will pay all the taxes that are due in the proper way.’


Not a great answer. Could do with more disguised spin. Glasgow MP, Anas Sarwar, had written such a good gag that he forgot to attach it to political point. Referring to the Findus scare, he said, ‘Many of the prime minister’s answers, if tested, may contain 100 per cent bull.’

Cameron giggled. ‘Best to get a grip of the issue and not just make jokes.’

Up rose the towering figure of Tristram Hunt with his suspicious eyes and handsome, disdainful face. Because Hunt is blessed with an exceptionally generous physique, the milk of human kindness has never reached every part of his body. Certainly not his brain. He accused David Cameron of closing 350 libraries. This atrocity, he declared, had been compounded by the Communities Secretary calling the anti-cuts protestors ‘a bunch of luvvies.’ This should have been a great moment for Labour. But the image of Eric Pickles, that redoubtable and Falstaffian figure, mocking a phalanx of celebrity protestors with this cheerful insult is irresistibly attractive.

As Hunt resumed his seat, Cameron re-defined the issue as a fight between noble volunteers and rotten Labour boroughs. ‘The Big Society has an important role,’ he said, ‘in keeping libraries open, sometimes in the teeth of opposition from Labour councils.’

Penny Mordaunt barely got her question out before the house erupted in catcalls. ‘Does the Prime Minister take a dim view of those who say one thing and do another… ?’

A clear a reference to the disqualified boy-racer, Chris Huhne, and the upcoming tussle for his vacant seat. Usually a mid-term by-election amounts to no more than a ritual execution. A little slice of Dignitas comes to a corner of the realm, and some hapless member of the governing party is done away with in a quiet and civilised ceremony. Not this time. Mr Cameron is so confident of victory that he launched his campaign on the floor of the house. He spoiled things a little by likening the Tory hopeful, Maria Hutchings, to a can of varnish. He also called her ‘it.’

‘Let the voters of Eastleigh choose a straight-talking candidate who does exactly what it says on the tin.’

He then stirred his troops on the eve of battle. ‘I hope all my honourable friends will be joining me on the campaign trail.’

The Tories whooped with glee. A good outing for Cameron toady. At least he thought so. Infallible clue: he mentioned the Big Society four or five times which always indicates self-confidence. He can’t wait for the can of varnish to seal it for the Tories.

Subscribe to The Spectator today for a quality of argument not found in any other publication. Get more Spectator for less – just £12 for 12 issues.

Show comments
  • yuvy

    Tristram Hunt with his suspicious eyes and handsome, disdainful face. Because Hunt is blessed with an exceptionally generous physique, the milk of human kindness has never reached every part of his body. suspicious

  • Colonel Mustard

    Gordon Brown asked and answered the questions all the time – and they were all connived to make attacks on the Tories who were in opposition at the time!

  • Daniel Maris

    “Cameron toady”…LOL There are quite a few in these parts.

  • Gary Clark

    a government that has ‘dealt with the banks……’ What an idiot!

  • Rousseau
  • Jenia Nyachowe

    I can never watch this Milliband chap without being reminded of a certain humourous character named Borat created by a Mr Ali Gee.

  • ScrewedMiner

    the tories should be sent to mine coal for the rest of their lives

    • HooksLaw

      I bow to all the leaders of the labour party who in their turn mined coal.

      I’ll tell you one thing, my father and his father and his father before him not to mention my fathers brother all mined more coal in one weekend than Arthur Scargill ever did.

    • yuvy

      after North Korea would take over. until than, ler freedom rule.

  • Fergus Pickering

    What do you mean Cameron toady. Who is he toadying to? Or do you mean he looks like a toad. But Red Ed looks much more like a toad.

  • Ken Ward

    typical journalistic twaddle.

  • Chris lancashire

    Can I suggest you take a couple of weeks off Lloyd? And use the time to study the Commons sketches of the excellent Anne Treneman.