Annals of Odd Complaint: Moaning that Google Does Exactly What You Say You Want It To Do - Spectator Blogs

20 November 2012

11:21 AM

20 November 2012

11:21 AM

Via Tim Worstall, here’s Jeanette Winterson:

A fiery Jeanette Winterson has called for the hundreds of millions of pounds of profit which Amazon, Starbucks and Google were last week accused of diverting from the UK to be used to save Britain’s beleaguered public libraries.

In an impassioned speech at the British Library this evening, the award-winning author of Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit said: “Libraries cost about a billion a year to run right now. Make it two billion and charge Google, Amazon and Starbucks all that back tax on their profits here. Or if they want to go on paying fancy lawyers to legally avoid their moral duties, then perhaps those companies could do an Andrew Carnegie and build us new kinds of libraries for a new kind of future in a fairer and better world?”

I have no view on Google’s tax arrangements save to observe that, as with Starbucks, those that do not like the way these companies do their business should lobby for the law to be changed rather than complain that Google et al are (one presumes) acting within the law.


Anyway, Winterson’s argument is still very odd. Because, even before it began to digitise millions of books, isn’t Google essentially, well, just a very large library? Just the kind of new library, in fact, that Winterson demands it be.

(And Amazon, of course, is the best bookshop any of us have ever had the opportunity to use.)

More Spectator for less. Stay informed leading up to the EU referendum and in the aftermath. Subscribe and receive 15 issues delivered for just £15, with full web and app access. Join us.

Show comments
  • Phil Bradley

    No, Google is not, by any stretch of the imagination a ‘very large library’. It’s simply a collection of stuff, in virtually no order. Google has little concept of what is required, is happy to return rubbish to a searcher, or even material that is specifically designed to confuse the searcher. It has no capability to work out what is required. A librarian on the other hand is clearly able to interpret, locate, check and return appropriate material to a user.

    You clearly have no concept of what either do.

  • LB

    BMW, Mercedes are dodgy UK tax by being incorporated in Bavaria.

    Time to tax those tax dodgers.

    Spot the flaw?

  • Shirley Burnham

    You have wilfully misunderstood Ms Winterson’s arguments, but I am sure the cleverness you think you have displayed here gives you huge satisfaction.

    • James R

      Shirley you can’t be serious ?

      • Matthew Whitehouse

        Shirley Knott

    • DavidDP

      Ms Winterson appears to have wilfully misunderstood the law, so both sides are square…….

Can't find your Web ID? Click here